Last updated: May 14, 2013
Cell phone and texting news: New York’s state Legislature is among the first to consider a total ban on cell phone use while driving. The bill was filed for the 2013-14 session by longtime distracted driving opponent Assemblyman Felix Ortiz.
Ortiz’s plan for a total talking & driving ban is unusual, but one that’s in line with the National Transportation Safety Board’s 2011 recommendation of total cell phone bans. Noting that New York was the first state to ban use of handheld cellular telephones while driving, Oritz says the state “must continue to be a leader in implementing measures to ensure the utmost safety of its citizens — and that is why New York must ban all use of cellular telephones while driving.”
Ortiz also filed three other pieces of distracted driving legislation: One seeks to ban the dialing of handheld cell phones while driving, another seeks to apply criminal penalties to drivers who kill or cause serious injury while talking on a phone, and the third would require police to detail cell phone use while writing accident reports.
- Read the New York regional distracted driving news & laws page.
Current distracted driving laws
- Drivers must use hands-free devices while talking on cell phones.
- Text messaging and related uses of handheld electronic devices banned.
- Taxi cab drivers in New York City banned from using cell phones.
Cell phone & texting legislation (2013-14):
Assembly Bill 3022: Would ban use of cell phones while driving, with the only exemption being calls seeking emergency assistance. No hands-free provision. Fine: up to $100. (Oritz)
A2668: Would ban display of video in front seat area of a vehicle, within view of the driver. Includes “prerecorded programming” for entertainment or business purposes. GPS and navigation screens exempted. Same as A4514 of 2011-12. (Wright)
A2884: Seeks to prohibit the “dialing” of mobile telephones by drivers. Would rewrite and replace existing state law to add dialing to definition of “using” a cell phone. (Oritz)
A1961: Would require police to indicate on accident reports whether a cell phone was in use at the time of the incident. (Oritz)
A2570: Seeks criminal penalties for drivers who, while using a cell phone, kill or injure another person. Would apply same penalties as for drivers who are under the influence. Two points against license in addition to other penalties, which could include prison time. (Oritz)
S3718: Would specify that the state texting & handheld cell phone laws apply when vehicles are stopped at stop signs, traffic lights, railroad crossings or due to heavy traffic. (Marcellino)
Distracted driving notes (2013):
Police wrote about 26,000 texting & driving violations in the first 11 months of 2012. New York County saw the most citations, followed by Monroe County.
A Queensbury woman has been sentenced to four years in prison for hitting and killing another woman while using a cell phone. The victim’s family asked for the maximum possible sentence in the negligent homicide case, and the judge agreed, handing down a 1 1/3 year to 4 year prison term on March 28. Deana Olsen, 36, killed Terry Brownell, 48, as she mowed her lawn in Kingsbury. The judge said he was “shocked and outraged” by Olsen’s claims she too was a victim. Olsen cried as the judge found her guilty in February, but a relative of the dead woman said, “It’s a little late.”
Assemblyman Felix Ortiz, sponsor of four distracted driving measures for the 2013-14 session, has numerous pieces of legislation addressing the problem since 1996. He was a key sponsor of the 2000 legislation that resulted in New York’s handheld cell phone ban for drivers. Ortiz, D-Brooklyn, seeks “to put an end to such senseless accidents and to keep our highways safe.”
The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office says it has so many complaints about distracted drivers that its web site now includes a report form. No one actually gets a ticket, but the alleged violators do receive a warning letter.
2012 distracted driving notes:
The number of texting tickets written in New York quadrupled in the year since the state cracked down on drivers distracted by portable electronic devices, officials said.
More than 20,000 tickets were written in the 12 months following July 12, 2011, Gov. Andrew Cuomo announced on the first anniversary of New York’s tougher distracted driving laws.
“The major increase in (texting) tickets … demonstrates (increased enforcement’s) usefulness in helping our law enforcement authorities crack down hard on distracted driving,” said Cuomo, top left.
In the year before the law was passed, New York law enforcement officials issued 4,569 texting tickets. (View a chart comparing texting ticketing in New York counties.)
A second Operation Hang Up crackdown on drivers who use handheld cell phones and text message ran April 23-29. Gov. Cuomo promoted the sweep with news that 150 drivers were stopped and cited in the first 12 hours. Cuomo also reported April 24 that more than 65,000 motorists have been busted for using handheld electronic devices so far in 2012.
Cuomo promoted the second federally funded Operation Hang Up during an April 24 appearance with safety groups in Battery Park City. “We hear too many heartbreaking stories about how distracted driving leads to tragic consequences, and we must do everything in our power to ensure more lives are not unnecessarily lost because someone took their eyes off the road to use a phone.”
New York state’s text messaging ticketing soared in the seven months since tougher enforcement of electronic distracted driving laws began in July 2011. Overall, law enforcement officers wrote almost 120,000 electronic distracted driving tickets July 12, 2011, to Feb. 7, 2012. Text messaging violations saw the most significant increase, to 7,495 tickets.
2011 distracted driving notes:
On July 12, 2011, Cuomo signed the get-tough legislation that upgraded enforcement of the texting while driving law to primary status. The governor also used administrative means to add another point against the licenses of distracted drivers.
The successful Assembly and Senate legislation removed the secondary enforcement status from the state’s text-message ban on drivers. The new law does not increase penalties for violators ($150), just increases the chances of their being pulled over and cited. It took effect immediately.
Cuomo’s third point applies to handheld cell phone violators, who are already targeted for primary enforcement (meaning police do not need another reason to stop and cite them).
New Yorkers who text and drive became subject to 2-point penalties in 2011. The rule change, effective Feb. 16, 2011, brings handheld cell phone violations in line with penalties under the state’s 2009 text messaging law.
The first full month under the state’s newly toughened distracted driving laws (August) yielded a record 1,082 tickets for texting, the DMV said. Year to date, more than 4,600 texting tickets have been written, already well above 2010′s total of 3,250.
With primary enforcement, the number of texting tickets more than doubled in 33 counties, Gannett reported, and more than tripled in a few other counties. (Cell phone tickets were in line with 2010 numbers.)
“I am proud to sign this bill today, both as the governor and as a father of three teenagers,” Gov. Cuomo said as he signed the tougher text messaging plan into law. “It’s plain and simple: distracted driving leads to tragedies that have affected families all across New York. This new law will help ensure that drivers keep their eyes on the road and their hands on the wheel. I thank Sen. Marcellino and Assemblyman Weisenberg for their hard work on this legislation.”
Cuomo decided to add the third point to distracted driving infractions at the administrative level because his plan did not advance in the Legislature.
Assemblyman Harvey Weisenberg, sponsor of A8106, said he received a congratulatory phone call from the governor’s office upon its passage, despite the presence of the competing measure from Cuomo. “I’m not going to kill our bill just because the governor came out with a recommendation,” Weisenberg, D-Nassau County, told the Legislative Gazette.
The sponsors of the primary-enforcement measure that passed the House and Senate — Weisenberg and Sen. Carl Marcellino — are the authors of similar measures introduced earlier in the session, including one that passed the Senate (SB 998b).
Weisenberg vowed to either get the bill through the Assembly or walk out. “We need tougher measures to crack down on texting while driving, and (to) send the message that our loved ones’ lives are simply not worth this unnecessary risk,” he said at a May 3 press conference just before the Senate approved S998b. Weisenberg sponsored the companion bill A6174.
Both the governor’s plan and the legislature’s plan would require distracted driving materials added to driver education courses.
S998 sponsor Sen. Marcellino, R-Syosset, said just before the vote: “Texting and driving is the ultimate distraction, taking all focus and attention off the road. The lethal nature of this epidemic mandates that we pass the primary ban now.”
Numerous city and county legislators have pushed for tougher local laws, pointing to the state law’s secondary enforcement. (View New York regional texting and driving legislation.)
Syracuse’s federally funded crackdown on distracted drivers ended April 16, with about 1,550 tickets written in the fourth, concluding sweep.
Syracuse’s revenues from distracted driving tickets issued in the four 2010-2011 sweeps totaled more than $400,000 as of August 2011, the Post-Standard reports. The majority of the funds came in surcharges attached to the tickets, which numbered 9,352. Money is still being collected as outstanding cases are settled.
The last of Syracuse’s federally funded distracted driving sweeps yielded 1,553 citations during its run April 7-16. “Understand, there will be a zero tolerance policy,” state police Maj. Donald DePass said at an opening press conference. “No excuses, no exceptions. We will continue to do enforcement until everyone gets it.” The breakdown: 1,371 for handheld cell phone violations; 182 for texting or using another electronic device.
The $300,000 program began in April 2010 and ended in April 2011. Law officers came from across Onondaga County and got overtime for their participation (more below).
The New York DMV commissioner says the Syracuse crackdown is a model program that could work statewide and nationwide. DOT chief Ray LaHood has praised the sweeps as a model for preventing distracted driving injuries and deaths.
A8106: Seeks to apply “primary enforcement” to New York’s texting while driving law. Introduced June 1. Approved by the Senate and Assembly on the same day, June 14. Sent to the governor who signed it into law on July 12. Same as S5643 (below). (Weisenberg)
SB 998b: Would remove “secondary enforcement” restriction to New York’s texting while driving law. Clarifies specific actions prohibited while using handheld electronic devices while driving. Requires a cell phone safety component to prelicensing education and testing. Fine: $150 plus 2 points against license (as before). Approved by the Senate on May 3 and sent to the Assembly (Transportation Committee). Governor signed plan into law on July 12. See A8106 above. (Marcellino)
S05643: http: Same as A8106, above. Introduced June 8 and approved by the Senate and House on June 14. (Marcellino)
A06174a Same as S998, above. (Weisenberg)
A4514: Would prohibit use of video devices that show prerecorded programming (DVD players) unless the screen is located behind the driver’s seat. GPS and navigation screens exempted. (Wright)
2010 text messaging legislation:
A10063: Makes driving and using a portable handheld device a primary offense in the state of New York, meaning law officers can stop and cite drivers for that reason alone. Filed at the request of the governor. Latest action: Approved by the Assembly in a unanimous vote on July 1. To the Senate, where prospects are uncertain. (Weisenberg)
S6992: Makes driving and using a portable handheld device a primary offense. Same as A10063, above. Filed at the request of the governor. (Dilan)
A09802: Would make use of a portable electronic device while driving a primary offense, given police the right to stop and cite violators for that reason alone. Also calls for distracted driving education efforts in pre-licensing materials and tests, as well as defensive driving courses and traffic school. (Quinn)
A09229: Changes wording of existing law against use of handheld electronics while driving. Would no longer require defendants to prove they were not violating the law, only to provide evidence that is “tending to show” no violation occurred. Same as S06810. (Gantt)
S06810: Same as A09229, above. (Diaz)
2010 distracted driving notes:
Syracuse received federal funding for its four-part crackdown on distracted driving. The latest (third) sweep in Onondaga County got under way in early October 2010 and runs for two weeks. The previous sweep started July 22 and ran through the end of the month. The DMV reported that 2,146 tickets were written for cell phone or text messaging violations in that period. In April, police cited 2,185 drivers for cell phone violations and 115 for text messaging. The fourth crackdown is set for April 7-16, 2011.
A September 2010 crackdown on use of handheld cell phones while driving on the New York Thruway yielded almost 1,000 tickets, troopers said. That makes more than 9,000 tickets in the past year. Thruway police are using unmarked vehicles in order to catch offenders.
New York State Police conducted their third “Operation Hang Up” sweep on the Thruway and I-84 (mid-Hudson Valley) during early May. The original “Hang Up” of 2009 yielded 816 tickets for use of handheld electronic devices.
New York Gov. David Paterson filed proposed legislation in February (“Program Bill 222″) to upgrade distracted driving legislation to primary enforcement. The resulting pieces of legislation are A10063 and S6992 (read the texting ban news story).
New York’s ban on cabbies’ use of cell phones resulted in more than 1,500 tickets during its first three months. The law, which went into effect Jan. 29, calls for $350 fines. Indignant fares can call 311 to report blabbing taxi cab drivers, the Taxi and Limousine Commission says.
Statewide, law officers have written about 2 million tickets for violations of the handheld cell phone ban since it went into effect in December 2001. The average rate of ticketing for cell phone violations over that nine-year stretch is 185 citations per 1,000 drivers, state motor department officials say. Almost 65 percent of the violations came in New York City.
On June 22, NYPD ran a sweep on drivers who text or talk on cell phones. The ticket crackdown covered the five boroughs.
A8568: Would ban use of portable electronic devices for all drivers. Covers text messaging, sending email, Internet browsing, game playing, etc. Fines would be up to $150 and violations would be secondary offenses, meaning police would need another reason for pulling over a driver. (The governor filed legislation in February 2010 to upgrade to primary enforcement.) Part of a larger driver safety bill sponsored by Assembly Transportation Committee chairman David Gantt. Approved by the Assembly and Senate in mid-summer and signed by Gov. David Paterson on Aug. 27. The ban took effect Nov. 1. The bill originated with Paterson’s motor vehicle department.
A2453: Would ban texting on a mobile phone while driving. Same as S587.
A6481: Seeks to ban text messaging while driving.
S1877: Would prohibit use of all cell phones and text messaging devices for drivers with learner’s and restricted licenses. Also cites “digital imaging and entertainment.”
S1547: Would require police accident reports to indicate whether cell phones contributed to crashes in New York. OK’d by the Senate. (Similar to the inactive A4184.)
A2031: Would ban drivers from using cell phones to send text messages. (Same as S741)
A00786: Proposes sanctions against “inattentive driving.”
2009 cell phone, texting legislation notes:
Assemblyman Felix Ortiz, D-Brooklyn, saw his text-messaging legislation incorporated into a larger driving-safety bill backed by Assembly Transportation Committee chairman David Gantt (A8568). “This was common-sense legislation that was overdue … and finally we have a bill that will keep our highways and roadways safe,” Ortiz said. The fine for text messaging and driving in New York state is $150.
Any state text-messaging ban would overrule city and country bans, which have spread throughout the state due to inaction in Albany.
Transportation Committee chairman Gantt has been under fire for stalling driver-safety legislation. A father whose teen daughter died in a drag-racing crash says, “We need to let people know who is standing in the way, like Gantt.” The New York Times called for his replacement over opposition to red-light cameras.
The Senate has approved S1547A, requiring police to report on the role of cell phones in crashes. The legislation passed on a vote of 47 to 12 on March 25, 2009. It has been returned to the House and assigned to the transportation committee.
New York was a leader in cell-phone restrictions on drivers, passing its widely copied hands-free law in 2001.
Text-messaging legislation, gained momentum after an upstate crash killed five teens. The driver’s cell phone was used to send and receive text messages just before the deadly accident.
“Text messaging is the ultimate distraction,” Senate sponsor Carl Marcellino, D-Long Island, told the Daily News. (Washington’s text-messaging ban took effect in July, 2008.)
2008 New York legislation:
S3195 and A7299: Would have added text messaging to current ban on drivers’ use of hand-held cell phones. Would create a “cell phone safety” component to driver education courses. The Senate approved the measure May 27, 2008. The legislation was last reported in the state Assembly transportation committee.
S8332: Would have prohibited teens under 18 from the use of any hand-held electronic device while driving. GPS navigation systems are included in the ban. Sponsored by Sen. Martin Golden, R-Brooklyn. Died in the Assembly Transportation Committee.
A05322: Would have prohibited drivers with learner’s permits or restricted licenses from using cell phones, with or without a hands-free device. Extends to all drivers under the age of 20 and all drivers in the first two years of holding driver licenses.
A05772: Drivers who cause injuries or deaths while distracted by a cell phone would have been treated the same as drunken drivers. Two points against drivers convicted of being in violation of cell phone laws.